Wars are not won only on the battlefield. Sometimes the enemy’s army is already demoralised, its society divided and its international allies have turned away from the state before the first shots are fired. From the propaganda leaflets of the First World War to the radio broadcasts of the Second and today’s Russian information operations against Ukraine, one pattern can be traced: influencing people’s minds has long been perhaps the decisive component of military strategy.

The First World War: propaganda as a tool for splitting the enemy

At the beginning of the 20th century, the world’s leading powers began creating special bodies to wage psychological warfare. They included printing presses, editorial offices, translation departments, units working with prisoners of war and censorship. Information influence gradually turned from an auxiliary tool into an organised area of state policy.

Each side tried to present its own participation in the war as just, relying above all on the rhetoric of national liberation. The Russian Empire called for freeing the Slavs from German, Turkish and Austro-Hungarian rule. Britain encouraged separatist movements in Germany and Turkey.

The main logic of psychological warfare consisted of two interrelated tasks: splitting the enemy camp and strengthening the unity of one’s own. Particularly telling was the work of the German secret services, which invested heavily in supporting the revolutionary movement in the Russian Empire. They helped opposition parties, printed anti-war literature in Russian and sent agitators to military units at the front.

After the 1917 revolution Russia left the war, which seriously weakened the Entente and changed the situation on the Eastern Front. Germany was able to advance across large territories almost unopposed. This experience showed how far-reaching the consequences of influencing an enemy’s internal politics could be.

At the same time, the technical capabilities of propaganda were expanding. The British built databases of postal addresses for targeted mailing of campaign material, while in the United States a network of lecturers received news from the front by telegram and spread it in hospitals, schools and churches. Information was beginning to work systematically not only on soldiers but on the broad population.

The Second World War: propaganda becomes a weapon in its own right

In the 1930s information warfare finally ceased to be merely an adjunct to armed struggle. The Nazi regime openly regarded propaganda as one of the main instruments for gaining and holding power. The development of radio gave psychological influence new possibilities: messages could now be spread quickly over large areas, bypassing traditional channels of communication.

In 1940 Germany began actively using so-called “black” radio transmitters disguised as French stations. They broadcast criticism of the French government and spread panicky rumours and defeatism. The aim was not simply to spread false information but to destroy trust in one’s own leadership and convince people that resistance was hopeless.

On the Eastern Front, psychological operations were even larger in scale. In 1941 the German propaganda ministry deployed 17 special companies, which in the first two months of the war alone distributed some 200 million leaflets. At the front line they used loudspeakers, propaganda bombs, and shells and mortar rounds filled with propaganda material.

In the occupied territories of the USSR, hundreds of newspapers were published, cinemas opened and cultural events organised. The population was told that Soviet rule was a thing of the past and that Nazi occupation was an irreversible reality. In this tactic it is easy to recognise today’s methods of Russian propaganda in the captured Ukrainian territories. The parallel is especially stark in Mariupol, where the Russian occupiers, amid the ruins of a city destroyed by their own army, repeat that Russia has come forever.

The Americans and British also used psychological operations, including methods of so-called black propaganda. Radio Luxembourg broadcast a programme called “Letters You Did Not Receive”, in which a woman’s voice read out extracts from letters found on the bodies of dead German soldiers. Leaflets spread stories of soldiers’ wives being unfaithful, and American aircraft dropped material on German cities asking: “Where is the Luftwaffe?”

The psychological effect of such methods was entirely practical. During the Allied offensive in Tunisia in 1943, Italian soldiers were willing to pay 600 francs for leaflets that served as passes to surrender. This was telling evidence that propaganda material could become a real instrument for influencing soldiers’ behaviour.

Vietnam: why convincing only the enemy is not enough

In the second half of the 20th century, psychological warfare became the subject of systematic military planning. In 1956 the United States created an Office of Special Warfare. Its task was to combine psychological techniques with other means of influence to undermine the enemy from within.

During the Vietnam War the US Army used special psychological operations battalions. They had their own printing presses, mobile film projectors and specialists who spoke Vietnamese. For the first time in the history of psychological warfare, television was used on such a scale: four Vietnamese-language channels were created, and thousands of television sets were handed out to the local population to increase the audience.

The Americans tried to build a positive image of their country even through everyday trifles. Local people were given chewing gum, cigarettes, toothpaste, toys and other gifts bearing American symbols. Psychological tricks designed to make the local authorities look weak were also used.

The Vietnam experience, however, revealed a fundamental problem: an information operation cannot be effective if it is aimed only at the enemy. According to a number of experts, one of the reasons for the American defeat was the loss of support from American society itself. Numerous youth protests discredited the US war in Vietnam. Theorists of psychological warfare therefore reached an important conclusion: information influence must cover not only the enemy but also one’s own population and armed forces.

The Persian Gulf: a victory prepared by information

The Gulf War of 1990–1991 was an example of the integrated use of information and military tools. After Iraq occupied Kuwait, the United States and its allies prepared a military response while keeping the negative experience of Vietnam in mind. Psychological operations units were given three tasks: convince American society of the need to intervene, secure international legitimacy for military action and demoralise the Iraqi army.

To coordinate information work, a joint bureau was set up to organise interaction with journalists from various countries. Media representatives were given access to military units, briefings and press conferences were organised, and prepared video material was distributed. At the same time, interviews with American servicemembers took place in the presence of public affairs officers who controlled the communication.

In parallel, relay transmitters were installed in Saudi Arabia to carry Voice of America and BBC broadcasts in Arabic. The same equipment carried a clandestine radio station, “Voice of Free Iraq”, prepared by American specialists. Its programmes criticised Saddam Hussein’s regime and reported on the military superiority of the allies. At the same time, electronic warfare systems jammed Iraqi government broadcasts.

According to the estimates cited in the source material, even before the ground operation began, 40 to 60 per cent of Iraqi troops were demoralised or psychologically suppressed. More than 70,000 Iraqi soldiers surrendered without a fight. Information preparation helped the allies isolate Iraq internationally, weaken its army and achieve their military objectives with fewer losses.

This example shows that a psychological operation can be not just an accompaniment to combat but part of a plan that determines its outcome before the active phase even begins.

Russia’s information war against Ukraine: the story continues

Today psychological operations are an integral part of practically every military conflict. Their aim is to influence people’s feelings, motives, critical thinking and behaviour. Information manipulation can be used to provoke social divisions, deepen distrust of the leadership, undermine economic stability and weaken a state’s ability to resist.

Russia’s propaganda machine was working against Ukraine long before the full-scale invasion. “Brotherly peoples”, “Crimea is ours”, “they’re not there”, the invented “crucified boy”, claims of a “genocide in Donbas” and the mythical Spanish air traffic controller Carlos were only the best-known examples of manipulation in earlier years. After 2022 new narratives were added: “where were you for eight years”, “Ukraine is shelling itself”, “Bucha was staged”, “the West is tired of Ukraine” and others.

Technologies, distribution channels and audiences change, but the basic logic remains the same: sow doubt, destroy trust, set citizens against one another and convince society that resistance is futile. That is why the information war will not end automatically once the shelling and fighting stop.

Destroyed cities can be rebuilt, infrastructure restored and people returned to peaceful life. It is much harder to restore trust that has been destroyed for years by deliberate propaganda. And perhaps this will be one of Ukraine’s main tests after the hot phase of the war ends: whether we can not only hold out on the battlefield but also preserve our ability to think for ourselves, tell truth from manipulation and not let the enemy decide who we are and how we see our own future.

Автор: Майданюк Валерій

Поділіться своєю думкою

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *